Designing a network using Cisco packet tracer

I'm trying to design a network for 10 cities. I opened a topic for this before and was informed about what I should pay attention to. But since I'm not sure if I did it right or not, I thought I should ask you again.

The 5 routers and PE1 router on the left side are routed with OSPF, the 5 routers and PE3 router on the right side are routed with OSPF. The routers between PE1 and PE3 routers are routed with BGP. Is this a correct and efficient network design?

Edited by Windays, 11 May 2024 - 08:42 PM.

You're on the right track

For reference:

https://www.bleepingcomputer.com/forums/t/797071/designing-a-computer-network-for-a-project-assignment/

Hello, @Windays:

There was no need to start a new topic for the same subject.
Having said that, we did not hear back from you about concerns raised in the previous thread (especially Replies #13 & #16) regarding external (expert) collaboration, and having others check your work for a school homework assignment. In many academic environments, this degree of active assistance & participation from other individuals would be discouraged or even prohibited. One's homework submission is supposed to be YOUR work-product.

Respectfully mentioned in the interest of academic integrity & to help ensure that your project is not disqualified

For reference:

https://www.bleepingcomputer.com/forums/t/797071/designing-a-computer-network-for-a-project-assignment/

Hello, @Windays:

There was no need to start a new topic for the same subject.
Having said that, we did not hear back from you about concerns raised in the previous thread (especially Replies #13 & #16) regarding external (expert) collaboration, and having others check your work for a school homework assignment. In many academic environments, this degree of active assistance & participation from other individuals would be discouraged or even prohibited. One's homework submission is supposed to be YOUR work-product.

Respectfully mentioned in the interest of academic integrity & to help ensure that your project is not disqualified

I'm new to the forums, I'll try to pay more attention to the rules. I'm not asking anyone to do the homework, I just tried to get an opinion on whether the design I made was correct or not.

Hi, again, @Windsay:

Perhaps you're missing the point because my concern was not clearly worded.
Sorry about that.

Asking other (more expert) persons for help (e.g., bullet lists of topics, external links & other guidance provided in your other thread, aa well as requests to review/critique/provide “opinions on” your work, etc.) crosses the line into outside collaboration (& possibly cheating) in some academic systems. Other persons need not “do your [entire] homework” project for it to be considered academic dishonesty & for the project to be disqualified.
One cannot, however, submit as one's own (at least without attribution) a project on which others have contributed, collaborated, reviewed & critiqued.

Perhaps your school permits this.
Perhaps not.

We have no inkling of the explicit or implicit rules & policies at your school. So, it's up to you to do the right thing.
It would be a shame if your hard work were to be disqualified.

EOD for me

Respectfully submitted

Cheers

Hi, again, @Windsay:

Perhaps you're missing the point because my concern was not clearly worded.
Sorry about that.

Asking other (more expert) persons for help (e.g., bullet lists of topics, external links & other guidance provided in your other thread, aa well as requests to review/critique/provide “opinions on” your work, etc.) crosses the line into outside collaboration (& possibly cheating) in some academic systems. Other persons need not “do your [entire] homework” project for it to be considered academic dishonesty & for the project to be disqualified.
One cannot, however, submit as one's own (at least without attribution) a project on which others have contributed, collaborated, reviewed & critiqued.

Perhaps your school permits this.
Perhaps not.

We have no inkling of the explicit or implicit rules & policies at your school. So, it's up to you to do the right thing.
It would be a shame if your hard work were to be disqualified.

EOD for me

Respectfully submitted

Cheers

I understand what you mean, thank you

One can guide but not do the work.